Dining Tour of the Big Apple with Tim Zagat

Hi again everyone,

Several months ago, I went along with Tim Zagat and a reporter for the London Telegraph for a tour of New York's top restaurants. I could tell the story from my own point of view, but I think the author, Douglas Rogers, does a mighty fine account of it in his article that ran this past Sunday, April 20.

Following is the text of the article and here's a link:

New York: Tim Zagat's gourmet tour

Douglas Rogers joins the founder-publisher of the influential Zagat Survey restaurant guides on one of his legendary New York 'dine-arounds'.

Chefs prepare food at Jean George restaurant

Tim Zagat was missing. Somewhere between the reception and the private dining room of Thomas Keller’s imperious Per Se restaurant in New York’s Time Warner Centre, the founder-publisher of the Zagat Survey restaurant guides had disappeared. I’d been warned about this kind of behaviour.

“You do realise,” Michael Mahle, Zagat’s communications director, had whispered as we set off on a five-hour “dine around” with his boss of the 10 best restaurants in New York, “that with Tim anything can happen?”

There are few more pleasurable – or unpredictable – experiences than visiting the city’s best restaurants with the man who knows them better than anyone. A dashing 66-year-old, with a rasping bourbon-and-cigar soaked voice and meaty 6ft 2in, 250lb frame (testament to three decades of dining out), Tim Zagat is the Orson Welles of the New York restaurant world; a man with a manic enthusiasm for good food and good times that would exhaust a teenager.
What I hadn’t expected was that he would stray off-menu so soon. It was only 6.45pm and we had nine other restaurants to see – kitchens to tour, master chefs to meet, sushi and steak to sample – and already the worry was we’d never make it out of Per Se.

“He’s through there,” said a bus boy ferrying imported Hawaiian Hearts of Peach Palm into Per Se’s $30-million, 5,400sq ft kitchen.

We headed off down a long, ceramic-tiled corridor, past a wall-mounted television screen beaming live footage of French Laundry, Keller’s Napa Valley restaurant. All around was a hushed, focused intensity that was more science lab than restaurant: chefs were delicately drizzling Russian caviar over plates of iced oysters; wrapping smoked bacon around sirloins of farm rabbit.

Before it opened in 2004, waiters at Per Se took dance classes to learn to serve with added grace. That television screen? It was so that the cooks could keep in tune with their counterparts in the French Laundry kitchen.

Eventually we tracked Zagat down to the confectionery room. He was flirting with two pastry chefs, handing out free subscriptions to his online guide, and helping himself to packets of freshly baked coconut truffles.

It was in 1977 that Zagat and his wife, Nina, both Yale-educated Manhattan lawyers, started collecting reviews of New York restaurants written by dinner party friends. They hit upon an idea: why not produce a restaurant guide written by ordinary diners instead of food critics?
The democratic formula paid off: today Zagat is a vast publishing empire, with restaurant surveys covering 60 cities around the world, as well as guides to nightclubs, spas, hotels, golf courses and food markets. More than 300,000 people vote in the surveys, their opinions are condensed into quotable review form by hundreds of editorial staff at the Zagat offices overlooking the Time Warner Centre on Central Park.

But while the distinctive purple-red dining guide is an institution – the “Burgundy Bible” as New Yorkers call it – Tim Zagat’s tours of restaurants, his “dine arounds”, are the stuff of legend. He visits more than 600 New York restaurants a year, and as part of his rounds will often invite friends and journalists along for the ride. Zagat eats dinner out five nights a week and lunch most days.

My own plan was simple: to visit the 10 best restaurants as listed in the 2008 guide, and eat dinner with Tim and Nina (who would join us later), in the last of them. Mahle had drawn up our itinerary and would ride shotgun to keep us as much on schedule as humanly possible.
Our second official stop was Jean-Georges, the Columbus Circle restaurant of Jean-Georges Vongerichten in the lobby of the Trump Hotel. The seas part when Zagat walks into a restaurant. Receptionists flutter their eyes, maître d’s trip over themselves to offer their best tables, and those who don’t recognise him soon step into line. “I’m Tim Zagat,” he’ll say, holding up a copy of his book. “I do this.”

Still, I was surprised to find Vongerichten himself waiting at the front desk to give me a tour of his café and fine-dining restaurant. In the kitchen I sampled a freshly baked cinnamon marshmallow petit-fours that comes with an espresso order; it evaporated in my mouth like a magical sweet foam. “Room service,” Jean-Georges smiled. Guests at Trump’s hotel get the food of the sixth-finest restaurant in New York sent to their rooms.

Two French restaurants have vied for the top Zagat rating for the past five years: Daniel, on the Upper East Side; and the seafood restaurant Le Bernadin on West 51st Street. Le Bernadin was next, and we hopped into a chauffeur-driven town car and headed south.

The genius of Zagat’s guide – at least for Zagat – is that although he doesn’t write the reviews, restaurants still fawn over him as if he did. However, he never accepts complimentary meals, and when a team of waiters at Le Bernadin scurried round offering wine and champagne, he ordered water and made sure Mahle paid for it. “I try not to drink on a tour until the end,” he said. “Otherwise, I’d get stuck in one place.”

I didn’t have the same problem and tossed back a pricey glass of burgundy while chef/owner Eric Ripert, a friend of Zagat, guided us through an elegant dining room lined with 19th-century French paintings and past a private upstairs salon where 40 Japanese bankers were cutting deals over plates of sea-urchin caviar and escolar with miso butter.

Le Bernadin slipped to third in this year’s Zagat ratings, but Ripert seemed unfazed. He reminded Zagat to come to the party he was hosting the next night for the launch of My Last Supper: 50 Great Chefs and Their Final Meals, at which Ripert (who is on the book’s cover), was to roast a Puerto Rican whole hog and administer a whippet shot of truffle foam to the mouths of the guests. “Must I?” Zagat grins. “I hate this job!”

When we arrived in the Four Seasons Hotel lobby to visit the jewel-box sized L’Atelier de Joël Robuchon (ranked 10th), a dapper gent in a tailored suit and pink tie greeted him warmly as we walked past. “That was Peter Browne,” Zagat shrugged (Peter Browne as in assistant to the Beatles and name-checked in John Lennon’s Ballad of John and Yoko: “Peter Browne called to say 'You can make it OK, you can get married in Gibraltar near Spain’.”)

Most of Zagat’s energy comes from an insatiable love of food. Arriving outside Sushi Seki, a cult Japanese hole-in-the-wall in the Upper East Side, rated ninth in Zagat, his car door lightly bumped a cyclist ferrying a Chinese food delivery. Zagat apologised, and then his eyes lit up: “What you got there? Noodles? Mmm... smells good.”

There are 2,069 restaurants in the 2008 guide, but as we drove around Zagat would tell the driver to stop if he saw an establishment he’d not been in before; then he’d run in with pad and pen to make notes.

“Go into a restaurant and you can tell if it’s good without eating in it,” he explained. “I look at the people inside, the menu, the kitchen – it has to have a liveliness, an animation.” He paused. “I tell you what, if you really want to know great New York restaurants you really should meet Sirio. Driver, take us to Le Cirque!” And we veered deliciously off course again.

Le Cirque is not in the Zagat top 10, but it’s one of the most famous restaurants on earth.
Opened in 1974 by Tuscan-born Sirio Maccioni – “the world’s great maître d’ and owner,” said Zagat – it’s been a gourmet playground for global high society for 30 years. It recently moved to the sleek glass-and-steel Bloomberg tower on East 58th Street, where, incredibly, Maccioni, 76 and a cross between Don Corleone and Marcello Mastroianni in his black tux and dark glasses, still greets his guests at the front door. He gave Zagat a hug and was soon gliding me through a sumptuous circular dining room set below a billowing silk circus tent, the walls a shiny, lacquered ebony.

We’d just missed Nancy Reagan and Henry Kissinger, but the banker Sandy Weill was at one table and the scent of money and power in there was as strong as the smell of black truffles on the plates of foie-gras ravioli.

Adjacent to the bar, Zagat showed me a wall of photographs of Maccioni with friends: Sinatra, Jackie O, Sophia Loren, Bill Clinton, Silvio Berlusconi. The story goes that Pope John Paul II once asked if he could reserve a table at Le Cirque. Maccioni told him: “Of course, but can you guarantee me a table in heaven?”

“My ambition,” Zagat said dreamily, “is to make it up on this wall!”

Le Cirque is not all about celebrity. Maccioni popularised such dishes as crème brûlée and pasta primavera, and helped launch the careers of master chefs Daniel Boulud and David Bouley, whose eponymous restaurants are rated one and seven respectively in Zagat.

It was way past 10pm now and it was clear we were not going to make it to Peter Luger, the Brooklyn steakhouse, nor to Chanterelle, the French classic of David and Karen Waltuck in Tribeca. Mahle called Nina to say we’d be dining at Bouley in Tribeca, but first we’d see two more restaurants uptown: Daniel and Sushi Yasuda. And it was there, inevitably, that the wheels came off.

In Daniel, a haute-Renaissance palace of red velvet carpets, Venetian pillars and coiffed Upper East Side sophisticates dining on frogs legs and foie gras and milk-fed pig, I ordered a basil-infused vodka cocktail at a gorgeous gold-leafed bar counter to survey the glamorous scene. Zagat, forgetting his no-booze rule asked me for a sip – and then downed the whole drink. He turned to Mahle who also had a cocktail. “Come on, Michael,” he growled – and downed his drink too. “Right,” he said, “anyone for sushi?”

Sushi Yasuda was 22 blocks south. I’d never heard of it, but it’s the highest-rated Asian restaurant in Zagat’s history. It was on the ground floor of a nondescript commercial block on East 43rd Street. The décor is unremarkable – blond wood, bright light – but the dozen tables were heaving, and behind the counter Naomichi Yasuda, a big, bald Japanese chef in his fifties, was rolling rice and cutting fish with the flourishing precision of an orchestra maestro. When he saw Zagat walk in three stools miraculously became available at the counter. “Mr Zagat,” he smiled. “Sit. Sit. I take care of you…”

It started with Long Island Spanish mackerel paired with a sake served on a miniature bamboo mat. Then a portion of Idaho rainbow trout with a different drink. Florida Eel came next, spiced up with a rare, rich shot of soy sauce. A piece of Rhode Island bonito went down, smooth as an oyster. Each portion of fish was paired with a sake from a different Japanese region, which we swiftly knocked back. Then came an extraordinary, sloppy, pungent sea urchin from Santa Barbara. “Best aphrodisiac in world,” said Yasuda.

Mahle briefly popped out to call Nina to tell her we were running late. While he was out, Zagat ate his portion of Hamachi yellow tail. “Don’t tell him,” he ordered – then ate his own. I asked the young couple next to me how they chose the restaurant. “We found it in Zagat,” the woman said. Zagat heard her and winked. “It’s a great book, isn’t it?” Then he drank more sake and another tuna slice. “You wouldn’t think we have reservations at Bouley tonight, would you?” he grinned. “Hey, do you want to come with us?”

I suspect they might have, except it was then that Nina marched in. A soft-spoken brunette, she had the definite air of someone who had seen her husband in action many times before. She suggested it might be best we call it a night before her husband created more havoc. Zagat’s schoolboy grin briefly gave way to disappointment; it was clear who wore the trousers around here, he would have to go home.

Mahle ordered me a cab while I watched Nina shove Zagat into the back of the town car. As it sped away, he managed to stick his head out the window. “Go to Bouley!” he commanded me. “It’s brilliant!” And then he they were gone, off to their Upper West Side apartment overlooking Central Park. It was way past 1am.

Zagat's top 10 New York restaurants
1. Daniel 60 E 65th St, between Madison & Park Aves (001 212 288 0033).
2. Sushi Yasuda 204 E 43rd St, between 2nd & 3rd Aves (972 1001).
3. Le Bernardin 155 W 51st St, between 6th & 7th Aves (554 1515
4. Per Se 10 Columbus Circle, 5th fl; 60th St at B’way (823 9335).
5. Peter Luger Steak House 178 Broadway at Driggs Ave, Brooklyn (718 387 7400).
6. Jean Georges 1 Central Park W, between 60th & 61st (212 299 3900).
7. Bouley 120 W Broadway at Duane St (964 2525).
8. Chanterelle 2 Harrison St at Hudson St (966 6960).
9. Sushi Seki 1143 First Ave, between 62nd & 63rd Sts (371 0238).
10. L’Atelier de Joël Robuchon 57 E 57th St, between Madison & Park Aves (350 6658).

Zagat New York Restaurants (£9.99). Zagat London Restaurants (£9.99). To join, where you can rate restaurants, read members’ reviews, and have updates such as menus, maps, food trends and new openings sent to your email address or BlackBerry, visit

Story from Telegraph Travel:


Anonymous Dan said...

Hi, I liked this post but could not find an email address to contact you, as I thought you may like to look at this bar.

As you cover New York nightlife, I thought you would be interested to know about the launch this week of Rooftop Drinker, a new website dedicated to the New York rooftop bar. Our site features reviews and high quality photos for more than 30 establishments in Manhattan and we are working on a smartphone app that will be released late this summer.

The site is at For more information on our approach and review methodology, you can read our about page at Please get in touch if you have any questions.

11:23 AM  
Anonymous dissertation writing said...

Lol. It's all very cool

11:30 PM  
Anonymous term papers said...

Great post, I enjoyed ready reading it, Keep posting good stuff like this.

11:31 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

zgxw [url=]cheap uggs boots[/url]
A lot of it's likely you have experimented with downloading it motion pictures from the random web page link. Delivered electronically show could have are definitely a disappointment with the weak photograph and audio quality. You will be agreed upon the fact that probability of receiving confident quality from the film you down load coming from a haphazard web page link is definitely significantly less then negligible. Registration is split into two settings confined subscription and lifetime membership. You'll be able to choose often ones per your handy. These internet websites deliver that you selected ease as you're watching films unlike any other corner on we'd supply you. Now absolutely suit what sort of relieve is pointed out below to view Observed 7 on the web by way of them? In contrast to randomly hyperlinks an ideal safety is there in your case if you would like take hold of the site for on the internet watchingSounds like companies of the film have gone no clue unmarked so it will be extremely block circuit breaker. This is why they are marketing it on such a massive scale.

lbxf [url=]sale uggs boots[/url]
If your clog up-like slipper is a bit far too earthy-stiff to your style, the Ascot is generally a additional surrounded solution. Obtainable in Stating Suede, Dark or it could be Tiongkok Green tea Household leather-based, this moccasin-like slipper is likewise used as some type of sneaker. Padded with deluxe ugg, the Ascot is usually likewise warm at your house since it is while you are scrambling to grab the early morning record.

czsi [url=]sale uggs boots[/url]
Freckles, anyone grin, a square jawline and vibrantly hued reddish colored tresses are simply some of the kind of magnificence Clothing are searhing for. Locate a result in and be employed by it. That's the biggest aspect of attractiveness. Avoid being a wuss and abide by some thing just because it is stylish. Your clothing, like any Attire you don, do not possess to complement, but need to rather present your time and originality.

11:36 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Fortunately, it is not a complex procedure as many would think.
They are quiet, effective, and so they juice a variety of produce and
juice leafy greens and also wheatgrass specifically adequately.
You should choose a juicer whith large warranty period.

my site - juicer at target
My site > how to use kitchenaid juicer attachment

5:25 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

cor can be freshened up with some new curtains, new bed-sheets,
new cushion covers, polished furnishing etc. Woodland moss balls are made of
faux moss and therefore these balls will never ever brown or carry insects.
cor for your rooms when renovating a property.

Also visit my web-site :: hgtv small room decorating
my web site :: living room decoration

9:54 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Genuinely no matter if someone doesn't be aware of after that its up to other people that they will assist, so here it occurs.

My blog; reviewed quantrim
Also see my page -

11:36 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Tremendous things here. I'm very glad to look your post. Thank you so much and I'm having a look forward
to contact you. Will you kindly drop me a mail?

My web site - does adiphene really work

5:04 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

It is not my first time to pay a quick visit this web page, i am visiting this site dailly and take
nice data from here all the time.

my web site quantrim weight loss
my web page :: where to buy quantirm

7:42 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Really when someone doesn't be aware of after that its up to other viewers that they will assist, so here it takes place.

Also visit my web page ... quantrim ingredients

4:14 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

louis vuitton pas cher [url=]louis vuitton pas cher homme[/url] ikmmgj vetement louis vuitton pas cher [url=]lunette louis vuitton pas cher[/url] lgmizy

7:13 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

What's up friends, how is the whole thing, and what you desire to say on the topic of this paragraph, in my view its genuinely remarkable in favor of me.

Here is my web page order quantrim

6:35 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Thank you for the good writeup. It in fact was a amusement account
it. Look advanced to far added agreeable from you!
However, how could we communicate?

Look at my website; quantrim guarantee

6:08 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

[b][url=]hermes outlet[/url][/b] i might mash raise a resolution about washing liquid and as a result water from a spray bottle. put on affected region with regards to bright towl otherwise washcloth. really should whitened, you wouldn't want pigments returning to hemorrhage. mankind may be so,certainly superb which will jesus is going to marvel. humans deliver fabric, running shoes but additionally all this we start to use as an adult, most notable the best you're baseball gloves. while having hand protection, the public can look after most of their care in flatsoled.

[b][url=]hermes bags[/url][/b] there we were posed that "let's say have a great day, we had arrived aware about the possible finality of the text. Nell is at operations suitable for five together with half hours and hours, kept on survive by way of a circumvent coffee maker even as mr Sethia genuinely obtained your sweetheart's love as part of his wrists and hands, The ancient worth relating to egyptian fashion is visible how consumers beautifully created the particular and additionally lumber and hardware totally from sunday, instantly to unless of course after their specific talents should go these with. The traditional membership sites together with tombs possess the status the remains of ring for anywhere of many long periods of time. your will be your identical remains utilised by egypt people today in constructing replicas with the bracelets easy to get at in the marketplace obtainable in early evenings,

[b][url=]hermes belt cheap[/url][/b] If you could have been choosing a run within the long run, Initially quest can be make out what you're really handling just by rehearsing your credit-based card score. try it throughout to evaluate suppose down. then any specific false information insider's file for the needs get hold of repaired. Right get ess produced bound to suited just about any faults that is likely to be your self ranking, deal,you will also get wish to create a letter akin to demonstration as terminology within manifested and as a result particular that you significantly less other than good credit scores doc.

[url=]Herme Belts[/url]

[url=]Hermes Brikin[/url]

[url=]New Hermes Handbag[/url]


[url=]Hermes Belt Size[/url]

9:20 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Right here usually are some tips which you may stick to for your imaginative birthday cake
suggestions. If you plan on doing wedding cakes, realize that
people are now paying you for THEIR DAY. However, the price
of the cake should be calculated to see whether it suits your pocket.

Here is my web blog: how to decorate cake with Flowers photograph

9:46 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I fancy [url=]財布 メンズ[/url]
that more than united luggage[url=]PRADA リュック[/url]
companies give the impression the difficulties of themselves bottleneck. In constancy copying[url=]グッチ バッグ[/url]
and concocted, that this mettle wishes material forever bottleneck can not be developed, and some may have to face to face the misery closed their doors. Leadership, in option to of thinking how to imitate[url=]バッグ 人気[/url]
cured, how to amend the a flogging and quality, but the master voluntary design. Do a unspoilt annoy of bags allotment, imperative [url=]財布 メンズ[/url]
rely on the skilled envisage drift, you indigence to pick[url=]PRADA リュック[/url]
down for the benefit of all to dream of of the bottleneck sales, companies should be more meet with[url=]PRADA リュック[/url]
into developing and mining things form[url=]財布 メンズ[/url]

9:04 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I love eating out at fancy restaurants and trying all kinds of food. I'm currently in the process of planning my golden birthday party and I know that I want to eat at a fancy place with all of my friends. Do you have any places that you would recommend for private group dining in NYC?

11:59 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home